Review: Ed Sheeran’s new album fails to meet already nonexistent expectations
You shouldn’t listen to this album. I’m going to start this off by saying it and saving you the 49 minutes you would waste listening to it.
Ed Sheeran released his fifth studio album, “=,” or “Equals,” Friday, Oct. 29. The album features 14 songs with two singles, “Bad Habits” and “Shivers” released beforehand. This album debuts two years after his last album, “No. 6 Collaborations Project.”
Sheeran tested positive for COVID-19 Sunday, Oct. 24, and cancelled his upcoming in-person performances.
I had no expectations for the album, and it still didn’t meet them. It couldn’t be more underwhelming than it is, even if we just took out production overall. Sheeran’s voice frankly does not fit the sound of the album. It’s too smooth, not matching up to the production – despite how underwhelming it was. I didn’t review all of the songs, but if you want more specifics, continue reading. But, if that’s all you need to hear, by all means, exit this article and go listen to Conan Gray’s new song “Telepath.”
“Tides”
Why call this song “Tides” when we can just call it “Rip-Off Castle on the Hill?” That’s all it felt like to me – besides the fact that I also thought it sounded like a horrible attempt for worship music.
Not only is the song well-below a decent attempt at an introduction, but the fact that this track then moves the listener to the next song, “Shivers,” makes “Tides” feel even more misplaced.
“Shivers”
Average. Underwhelming. Annoying. Do I even need to go on? The fact that this was released as a single baffles me, as usually artists release their best songs as singles, but there’s no way “Shivers,” or even “Bad Habits,” were the best of the album.
The mix between guitar-ballad like production and techno-beats does not blend well together, and doesn’t match the lyrics or the vocals either.
As for the music video, I can kind of see what he was going for, but it really just gave off bad-Lady Gaga-impersonator vibes. I’m not really sure what was going on in the video, but it definitely didn’t match the bland song.
“First Times”
Sheeran was definitely attempting something here, but he missed the mark by miles. Not only was it forgettable, but he also tried to sing too high at some points, so his voice got whispery. The only redeeming part of the song were the violins, because I love violins.
The production was definitely the best aspect of this track. But, even then, it gets repetitive and annoying after a while. Just like “Tides,” this track seems misplaced coming from the upbeat “Shivers.” While the lyrics are quite relatable, and are of high quality and emotional connections, specific moments of the song just seem too far-stretched in his vocal abilities.
“Bad Habits”
This song is already way too overplayed. It feels misplaced coming after “First Times,” and I have doubts it should have been released as a single, rather than the typical song in the middle of an album that you forget about. The music video for this was also extremely weird, and, for me, had no point to it, as it didn’t relate to the song at all.
“Overpass Graffiti”
I actually might have to consider this one of the best of the album – which I guarantee is not a compliment – as it had an almost-good beat. After listening to this track, you can’t help but feel like this was a “The Weeknd” track, mixed with more 80s-style aspects. The track, however, is ruined by the merely disappointing, and creepy, music video. It looked like a nature documentary. It just didn’t make sense to me.
“The Joker and The Queen”
This track is probably one of the worst ballads I’ve ever heard. To be honest, this track tries to mix in Adele-like vocals, Sia-like songwriting progressions and Kanye-like weirdness. It is not a good match, especially for an adult male in a pop album. In my opinion, Sheeran strains his vocals on this track trying to fit an emotional appeal when tied in with the songwriting, and it ends up just being a mess.
“Collide”
The beat had potential to be good, but for some reason, it just was not. A mix of tropical sounds, hip-hop beats, and backing synths, the production has a lot of potential. The track reminded me of a Killers song, but then again, Ed Sheeran’s vocals didn’t match up with the energy.
“2Step”
This song had potential to be good, if it was sang by another artist. The tone quite frankly doesn’t fit Sheeran’s voice, but the overall lyrics of the song, if sang by someone else, I could see being a popular song.
“Sandman”
The whole song sounds like a kids jingle and it’s incredibly odd. Definitely not a fan of this one, and, as per the theme, it was boring. If you are the type of person who likes tracks like these, you’d be much better listening to recent tracks by “The Tones & I,” because Ed Sheeran’s take on this song type is embarrassingly awkward to listen to. After finishing the track, I couldn’t help but notice the resemblance to the game “Hay Day.”
“Be Right Now”
The beat definitely tried to serve something, however it served absolutely nothing. The production not only felt off, but it also completely overpowered his voice. The background distortion on his vocals accompanied the beat nicely too, but it felt overly repetitive. The deep piano didn’t match his vocals either, but the overall vibe of the song wasn’t the worst on the album. The lyrics are pretty relatable and deep, but once again, the match between his vocals and the production were not good.
Final Opinions
Overall the album was underwhelming, boring and forgettable. I will never listen to it again, nor remember these songs minutes after writing this.
Sheeran’s biggest downfall is that his voice just doesn’t fit pop. It sounded much better with his earlier music like “Photograph.” However, it just doesn’t fit this kind of production. I think this is why the whole album came out underwhelming: his vocals just don’t match the already-lackluster production.
His music videos also had the worst vibe. I know he was trying to go for the unique style that’s growing more popular these days, but he completely missed the mark, just giving off “The Weeknd” vibes with most of the videos. It just ended up chaotic – in a bad way – and some of them were even so weird that it made me uncomfortable.
Another big thing I noticed is that most of the songs sounded similar to either “Shape of You” or “Castle on the Hill,” almost as if he was trying to replicate their success. Most of the tracks seemed like they were copying either song, and it definitely did not work.
If you’ve somehow made it all the way to the end of this album review, please just take our advice and not listen to the album. It’s not worth your time or money.
Your donation will support the student journalists of Prosper High School. Your contribution will allow us to purchase equipment and cover our annual website hosting costs.
Honors & Awards:
Best of SNO – "Feline friendship, Instagram allows family to help soldier" with Amanda Hare.
Best of SNO – "Junior overcomes dancing accident, bone transplant" with Christi Norris.
Best of SNO – "Podcast: History’s Forgotten – Season 2 – Episode 1 – Charles Whittlesey" with Amanda Hare & Christi Norris.
Best of SNO – "Podcast: History’s Forgotten – Season 2 – Episode 3 – Veterans Day" with Amanda Hare & Christi Norris.
2021 TAJE Honorable Mention – Caption Writing
2021 TAJE Honorable Mention – Story Portfolio
2021 Academic All-State
TAJE Fall Fiesta Honorable Mention – Video News Story "ENN students share common goals, look forward to new season"
Honors & Awards:
2022 TAJE Texas Journalist of the Year
2019, 2021 UIL State Headline Writing Champion Runner-Up
2022 UIL State Meet: 3rd place Headline Writing, 4th place News Writing, 7th place Editorial Writing
UIL Headline Writing Regional Awards:
2019: 2nd place
2020: 2nd place
2021: 3rd place
UIL Editorial Writing Regional Awards:
2020: 2nd place
2021: 4th place
20 Best of SNO publications
2021 National NSPA Story of the Year Honorary Mention
2021 National NSPA Top 10 Best of Show Podcast
2021 TAJE Best of Texas: Excellent Story Portfolio, Superior News-Feature Story, Honorable Mention Headline Writing
2021 TAJE Fall Fiesta: Superior Headline Writing, Superior Interview Podcast, Excellent Video News Story, Excellent Video Feature Story
2022 TAJE Best of the Best: 3rd place Online News Portfolio
2022 TAJE Best in Texas: Excellent Interview Podcast, Superior Story Portfolio, Honorable Mention News Story, Honorable Mention Feature Story, Excellent In-Depth Package, Excellent Entertainment Feature, Excellent Headline Writing
2022 NSPA Best of Show: 7th place Editorial Board Leadership, 4th place Podcast
2022 ILPC 6A Awards: 2nd place Sports Feature Story, 3rd place Feature Writing, 3rd Place Entertainment Review, 1st Place In-Depth News/Feature Package, 1st Place Photo Slideshow, 1st Place Video Story, 1st Place Multimedia Package, Honorable Mention Portrait, 3rd place Headlines
2022 Tops in Texas Awards: Photo Slideshow, Multimedia Package
2021 TAJE Student Advisory Council Member
2020-2022 PHS Newspaper Student of the Year
NSPA Student Journalist National Honor Roll
Quill and Scroll Honor Society Member
Honors & Awards:
NSPA Top 10 National Finalist – Writer/Portfolio of the Year
2021-2022 UIL State Headline Writing - 6th place
2021-2022 UIL Regional Headline Writing - 2nd place
2021-2022 UIL District Headline Writing - 1st place
2020-2021 UIL District Feature Writing 1st place, Headline Writing 2nd place
2020-2021 UIL Regionals Feature Writing 4th place, alternate to UIL State
18 Best of SNO publications
10 individual ILPC placements
3 Best in Texas Superior Ratings, 4 Excellent Ratings, 3 Honorable Mentions
2021 TAJE Fall Fiesta Superior Rating - Live Feature Writing
PHS Writer of the Year, 2020-2021
NSPA and TAJE Student Journalist National Honor Roll
Quill & Scroll International Honor Society member
National Honor Society member
Jokerandthevamp • Jan 13, 2022 at 11:55 pm
Wow. This review made me lose braincells. How are you going to critique an entire album by listening to not even half the tracks and then make an assumption for the entire album, when not hearing Visiting Hours which was dedicated to his late friend Michael Gudinski. And to top it off with the sidebar asking the readers to watch for Conan Gray’s latest music as if he isn’t more generic and boring than Ed’s newest album. I, for one, think the album was generally more appealing and listenable than his last two albums combined. But the whole review of this is just embarrassing and can’t even tell if it’s a joke.
Amanda Hare • Jan 14, 2022 at 10:18 am
Hi! Thank you for reading! We all listened to every song from the album when writing this review. Thank you for providing your feedback! 🙂
Seshli Aram • Nov 11, 2021 at 3:13 pm
Music is ultimately an art and not a science– expressing your opinion as a fact is never a good way to gain the trust of your readers. No one is entitled to say more about art than “I liked it” or “I didn’t like it,” unless the criticism is humble and constructive. This article takes the form of invective, since it is vastly opinionated; the poll at the end expresses the linear perspective succinctly. I don’t have to disagree with the opinion in this article to disagree with the way in which it is presented.
Amanda Hare • Nov 15, 2021 at 7:44 am
Hi! Album reviews are opinion articles labeled as “review,” so no opinion is presented as a fact. Reviews reflect the opinion of the writers. Thank you for reading!