Review: ‘Shadow and Bone’ books enchant readers until they can’t look away
Alina Starkov is a nobody.
In a country plagued with a centuries-old war and a sea of darkness better known as “the Fold,” Alina is an insignificant soldier and map maker. What makes Alina even more unimportant, though, is her non-existent lineage as an orphan, and her inability to use the “small science” as Grisha do.
Everything changes for better or worse when Alina gets sent to cross the Fold with several other soldiers, and ends up fending off an attack by dangerous monsters, otherwise known as the volcra, that live there. During the attack, Alina realizes that her best friend, Mal, is in danger, and rushes to his aid. Before she can understand what’s happening, though, the world around her erupts into a blaze of light, scaring off the volcra. Alina emerges from the volcra attack on the same side of the Fold that she departed from, confused and worried for Mal. What Alina doesn’t know, however, is that the blaze of light that saved them was created by her.
After Alina’s ability is discovered, she is taken to see The Darkling, a man who leads the second army, an army of Grisha. He labels her as the “Sun Summoner” — a person of mythical powers discussed in prophecies as the person who will save Ravka from the Fold. He tries to keep her identity secret, and escorts her back to Os Alta — the capital of Ravka — where she is taught to use her powers.
What Alina doesn’t know, though, is that she has no real friends in The Little Palace that she now calls home. Her story becomes one of betrayal, pain, and sacrifice, but throughout it all, Alina remains hopeful that she can fulfill her new destiny and destroy the Fold.
Personal Opinions
The “Shadow and Bone” series by Leigh Bardugo is by far one of the best fantasy series ever written. Bardugo creates a perfect balance of keeping the reader anxious while not overwhelming them with continuous fast-paced scenes. Every character is compelling, as we either loved someone or loved to hate them.
The trilogy was engaging and each book was equally great. There wasn’t one book that we felt was worse than the others, a common problem in other trilogies. All three are what we would consider “page-turners.”
Alina was a great protagonist, too. Her character development from an unknown girl to a powerful Grisha was masterful and satisfying to see. We loved how she embraced her role of “Sun Summoner,” while also not becoming arrogant with her new saint status.
The love triangle — a love square at some points, really — was a rollercoaster, yet we loved it. We were always conflicted over who we thought was best for Alina. Our favorite in the end, though, was definitely Nikolai. He was caring for Alina and treated her right, while we thought The Darkling treated her terribly, and we felt Mal didn’t accept her Grisha side. Nikolai was even our favorite character of the series. He was entertaining and kind, and his character development was excellent.
Furthermore, every plot twist in the series was unexpected and mind-blowing. We didn’t expect a single one, and we loved it. They were well-thought-out and made sense, while still completely changing the course of the story.
Overall, the series sucked us in, not letting us put it down until we reached the end. It was perfectly-paced and satisfying with compelling characters in a fascinating fantasy world.
Your donation will support the student journalists of Prosper High School. Your contribution will allow us to purchase equipment and cover our annual website hosting costs.
Honors & Awards:
2021 Online Tops in Texas 9th place
Dallas Morning News National High School Competition 1st place
Photographer Of The Year Prosper High School 2019-2020, 2020-2021
National Scholastic Press Association (NSPA) Best of Show Awards 4th place podcast
Southern Interscholastic Press Association (SIPA’s) Best Writing Contest 2nd place blog
Interscholastic League Press Conference 2021 Individual Achievement Awards:
1st and 2nd: Photo Slideshow
Honorable Mention: Student Life Photo
3rd: Photo Portfolio
Honorable Mention: Sports Feature Photo
3rd: Sports Action Photo
3rd: Feature Photo
2nd and 3rd: In-Depth News/Feature Package
Interscholastic League Press Conference 2020 Individual Achievement Awards:
Honorable Mention: Photo Slideshow
Honorable Mention: Photo Portfolio
Honors & Awards:
2022 TAJE Texas Journalist of the Year
2019, 2021 UIL State Headline Writing Champion Runner-Up
2022 UIL State Meet: 3rd place Headline Writing, 4th place News Writing, 7th place Editorial Writing
UIL Headline Writing Regional Awards:
2019: 2nd place
2020: 2nd place
2021: 3rd place
UIL Editorial Writing Regional Awards:
2020: 2nd place
2021: 4th place
20 Best of SNO publications
2021 National NSPA Story of the Year Honorary Mention
2021 National NSPA Top 10 Best of Show Podcast
2021 TAJE Best of Texas: Excellent Story Portfolio, Superior News-Feature Story, Honorable Mention Headline Writing
2021 TAJE Fall Fiesta: Superior Headline Writing, Superior Interview Podcast, Excellent Video News Story, Excellent Video Feature Story
2022 TAJE Best of the Best: 3rd place Online News Portfolio
2022 TAJE Best in Texas: Excellent Interview Podcast, Superior Story Portfolio, Honorable Mention News Story, Honorable Mention Feature Story, Excellent In-Depth Package, Excellent Entertainment Feature, Excellent Headline Writing
2022 NSPA Best of Show: 7th place Editorial Board Leadership, 4th place Podcast
2022 ILPC 6A Awards: 2nd place Sports Feature Story, 3rd place Feature Writing, 3rd Place Entertainment Review, 1st Place In-Depth News/Feature Package, 1st Place Photo Slideshow, 1st Place Video Story, 1st Place Multimedia Package, Honorable Mention Portrait, 3rd place Headlines
2022 Tops in Texas Awards: Photo Slideshow, Multimedia Package
2021 TAJE Student Advisory Council Member
2020-2022 PHS Newspaper Student of the Year
NSPA Student Journalist National Honor Roll
Quill and Scroll Honor Society Member