Talonette takes a knee to ‘take a stand’ in National Anthem controversy
When the crowd stands as the first note of the “National Anthem” rings throughout the stadium, Talonette and junior Karolina Rubio drops to a knee.
Despite the disapproving whispers, she said she just kept smiling, with the belief that this small action could help bring about the change the Black Lives Matter movement has been seeking.
After the death of George Floyd this past May, the Black Lives Matter movement has exploded across the country with protests, riots, and social media blackouts. Many students have expressed their support of the movement through social media and protests, but Rubio has taken her activism a step further by kneeling during the National Anthem at the high school football games she performs at. Rubio is an active supporter of the Black Lives Matter movement, and said she believes in solving injustice through peaceful protesting.
“With all of the racial tension that’s going on with minorities pushing back against systemic racism and with the protests going on, I felt like I needed to do something as a minority myself,” Rubio said. “For me, that was kneeling during the National Anthem.”
While he cannot speak to the issues surrounding Rubio’s protest, assistant principal John Boehringer said laws and policies are in place to support students who wish to peacefully protest and practice their constitutional rights.
“Prosper High School encourages all students to exercise their First Amendment rights,” administrator John Boehringer said. “A student may always engage in non-disruptive protest activities. The Tinker vs. Des Moines case has long established that ‘students do not shed their constitutional rights of freedom of speech or expression at the schoolhouse gate.’ A student may engage in a protest action or a protected speech action, provided that it does not create a disruption to the school environment. I encourage all of our students to know and exercise their constitutional rights, and I’m always available to discuss these issues if students have questions.”
While Boehringer said students are free to exercise their First Amendment rights, he believes students should consider the effects after high school when they make the choice to kneel or peacefully protest.
“I would remind all students that what gets posted online tends to exist for a long time,” Boehringer said. “A student engaging in a protest-speech action in a public venue is likely to be photographed and even named, online. This could lead to associations, positive or negative, for that student far down the road in their future if a future college, employer, date or other party were to search for information about them online.”
A few members of the Talonettes have expressed their support for Rubio’s peaceful protest.
“It’s her right to do it. The real people at fault are the people that commented or direct messaged her hateful stuff on Instagram and did downright disgusting things,” freshman Talonette Kalila Beak said. “Prosper should be showing positivity and supporting each other.”
As with any controversial statement, Rubio received backlash from her peers on multiple social media platforms.
“I knew that I go to a predominantly white school with ideals that are predominantly conservative, so I knew I was going to face some backlash,” Rubio said. “I wasn’t expecting it to be as bad as it was. It made me very anxious knowing that there are people that feel this strongly against me. I was terrified that they would come and hurt me in person. It was eye-awakening and very scary.”
Despite the backlash, Rubio does not plan to stop.
“To anyone out there who wants to take a knee and take a stand against the injustices in our country, I say absolutely go for it because it’s something that needs to be done,” Rubio said. “There will be people who fight back, but ignore them and keep doing what you’re doing and standing up for what you believe.”
Your donation will support the student journalists of Prosper High School. Your contribution will allow us to purchase equipment and cover our annual website hosting costs.
Honors & Awards:
2 Best of SNO publications
Dallas Morning News National High School Competition 1st place
Quill and Scroll National High School News Competition 2nd place
Quill and Scroll Honor Society Member
2020 TAJE Fall Fiesta: Superior Portrait, Honorable Mention News-Feature Photo
2021 TAJE Fall Fiesta: Excellent Sports Reaction, Honorable Mention Feature Photo
Interscholastic League Press Conference 2021 individual achievement awards:
Top in Texas: Feature photo
2nd: Photo Slideshow
3rd: Portrait
Honorable Mention: News Feature
Victoria Trueheart • Sep 29, 2021 at 11:23 am
Its a song. Wheres the outrage for the injustice the rest of the world thinks the USA is known for? Fake outrage for teens over a song that doesn’t bring unity. This is the world we’ve come to.
Jacob Joehanson • Jan 5, 2021 at 3:12 pm
The amount of people who lost their lives fighting for this Country is the reason people should not kneel for the National Anthem.
Christian Sheehan • Dec 21, 2020 at 11:44 pm
lol liberal
nicole bitner • Dec 20, 2020 at 1:05 pm
very nice article. extremely well written and unbiased. if anyone has an issue with it that is their fault. y’all are doing a great job
Kyle Swackhammer • Dec 20, 2020 at 1:19 am
I’m a former student at PHS and I am saddened by this stunt and the reaction it possessed. There is nothing short of disrepect in this act of kneeling in the face of our national anthem and our flag. Although I support the freedom of expression as protected by our first amendment in our United States Constitution, there is nothing brave about it. Bravery is acknowledging the call to arms and crawling up the blood covered sandy beaches of Normandy against the odius apparatus of the nazi rule. Bravery is scouting in booby trapped jungles and rice paddies against a hidden enemy in tunnels sinking deep into the terrains of Vietnam. Bravery is bleeding and risking everything for two United States facilities in Benghazi, Libya against the onslaught of the Islamic militant group Ansar al-Sharia on September 11, 2012. There is not act of bravery in this stunt performed by this talonette. Not the slightest hint at all.
Anna Corbeill • Dec 19, 2020 at 11:11 am
I’m a former student at PHS and all I have to say is I’m so thankful somebody has the guts and dignity to “stand” up for what they believe in and I fully hope that Karoline continues to do what she does and I send my whole heart and prayers that she can do so peacefully without and violence or disgusting actions towards her or others that participate in any sort of protest.